|
|
|
|
|
Sumario
Nº 1
> Immune
System
|
|
|
|
|
The Immune System as a Marker of Health and Longevity
|
|
Dr.
Mónica De la Fuente
Professor of Physiology. Faculty of Biological Sciences, Complutense
University
|
|
|
 |
SUMMARY |
| |
The function of the immune system is to recognize
the "self" or identity of each individual and to destroy
foreign microorganisms and tumor cells. It has been shown that
a well preserved function of the immune cells is an excellent
marker of health and, accordingly, we have confirmed that the
functional competence of leucocytes, determined by means of a
battery of parameters that change with age, is a marker of "biological
age" in human subjects as well as in laboratory animals.
Further, we have found that in our model of premature ageing in
mice the immune function biomarkers are good predictors of longevity.
Thus, the mice showing immune parameters characteristic of animals
of older chronological age have a lower life expectancy than those
which as regards their immune function are "biologically
younger". In relation to the above, it is proper to consider
why the immune functions are altered in the aged organisms. In
our opinion, the senescence of immune cells, like that of other
cell types, is probably due to the oxidative stress (linked to
raised production of free radicals and decreased antioxidant defense)
that occurs with age. Moreover, we suggest that the immune system,
because of its need to produce free radicals (FR) and other oxidant
and inflammatory compounds in order to support its functions,
is very involved in the oxidation/inflammation process that underlies
senescence. This view justifies present attempts to prevent age-related
oxidative stress by diet supplementation with antioxidants. Accordingly,
as regards the immune system a number of studies, performed both
in human subjects and in experimental animals, has shown that
the ingestion of antioxidants by aged individuals changes the
functional parameters of leucocytes, bringing them to levels similar
to those of the adult. This immune "rejuvenation", that
is accompanied by an increased longevity in the experimental animals,
supports the oxidation/inflammation theory of ageing and the useful
role of the investigated leucocyte functions as markers of life
expectancy and health.
Key words: Immune System. Aging. Oxidative stress. Antioxidants.
|
| |
|
 |
THE
IMMUNE SYSTEM |
| |
Since we are born we are continuously
exposed to suffer infectious and carcinogenic processes that might
result in death if the organism did not have at its disposal a complex
physiological system that protects us against those processes, namely
the immune system. This system is composed by a large variety of
cells and molecules able to recognize and eliminate a great number
of different agents foreign to the organism, which comprise not
only the invading microorganisms but also our own cells that are
continuously exposed to tumorigenic mutations. The immune cells
have a wide functional competence and present multiple and complex
forms of communication. The mechanisms used by the leucocytes in
order to carry out their functions, the so-called "immune response",
are based on the following steps: (a) recognition of the foreign,
i.e., the antigen. (b) Activation against this antigen, that is
very well regulated, since an uncontrolled activation of the immune
system may be the cause of pathological processes and mortality.
(c) Destruccion of the foreign agents (infectious microorganisms
or cells that have suffered a malignant transformation).
In view of the above, the immune system is uniquely suited to recognize
our integrity, i.e., our own self and thus be able to defend us
from foreign pathogenic agents. On the basis of the above, since
it is obvious that an adequate leucocyte function is essential to
insure a correct organismic function, the functional competence
of leucocytes has been recommended as one of the best biomarkers
of the health of a subject and therefore of his life expectancy
(1). Moreover, since the immune system has a key role in the preservation
of homeostasis, this system is presently considered a genuine regulatory
system, comparable to the "classic" regulatory systems,
namely the nervous and the endocrine systems (2-4). |
| |
|
 |
THE
NEUROENDOCRINE-IMMUNE SYSTEM |
| |
It is worth mentioning that the
immune system (IS) does not work in isolation but it functions in
close relationship with the other regulatory systems of the organism,
namely the nervous and the endocrine system. This bidirectional
communication between the regulatory systems was confirmed in the
seventies by Besedowski et al., who found that the glucocorticoid
levels, which increased during the immune response, had a suppressor
effect on that response (5). Further work by Besedowsky and other
workers confirmed the above mentioned system connections (6-8).
Thus it was accepted that the IS represents a system of reception
of information of non-cognition related stimuli that appear in the
organism (infections, tumor cells or other types of foreign cells)
and response to those stimuli, accompanied by transfer of that information
(by means of the cytokines produced by I.S. cells) to the neuroendocrine
system. On the other hand, the neuroendocrine system is a receptor
of cognitive stimuli (light, sound, stress situations, etc.) to
which it responds, and its mediators (neurotransmitters and hormones)
rech the I.S to inform it about the situation. Thus, there is a
neuroendocrine-immune system that allows the preservation of organismic
homeostasis and therefore of health. The scientific confirmation
of this communication has allowed to understand, on the basis of
the experimental data, a number of facts of everyday life. Thus
it is well known that the situations of depression, emotional stress
or anxiety, provoked for instance by the loss of the job or of a
close relative, are accompanied by a greater vulnerability to conditions
ranging from infectious processes to cancer or autoimmune diseases,
which agrees with the concept that the IS is impaired, which results
in worse health and a shorter life span. By contrast, pleasurable
situations and an "optimistic outlook" on life help us
to overcome IS-related diseases and enjoy a better overall health.
Conversely, it has been shown that IS changes such as found in infectious
processes alter nervous system functions, which can even lead to
psychotic disorders. Presently it is accepted that the three above
mentioned regulatory systems share receptors and therefore any influence
exerted on the IS will have an effect on the nervous and endocrine
systems and viceversa. |
| |
|
 |
AGE-RELATED
CHANGES IN THE IMMUNE SYSTEM |
| |
The impairment of the IS with age,
i.e. the immunosenecence, exerts a great influence on the increasing
morbility and mortality observed in aging human subjects (1). In
fact, it is well known that with the passage of time there is a
decrease in the resistance to infections, and an increase in autoimmune
processes and cancer, which indicates the pressence of a less competent
I.S. Moreover, the increased death rate found in aged populations
is due in great proportion to infectious processes (9-10). In view
of the key role of an optimum immune function in the preservation
of health, it seems logical that one of the theories on the cause(s)
of aging, namely the "immunological theory", maintains
that the responsability for the changes that take place in the organism
with the passage of time lies on the impairment of the immune defense
system (11,12). Nevertheless, despite the fastly-increasing amount
of data on immunosenescence, the changes in the immune functions
with age as well as the specific role played by the IS in organism
ageing is not well understood. This may be due to the great complexity
of both organismic ageing and of the aging process of the IS, with
its diverse cell populations and subpopulations, and the interactions
among themselves as well as with other physiological systems.
Although the immune cells change their functional competence with
increasing age, not all immune cell types show a significant impairment.
In fact, several cell types are more functional with age whereas
other types do not show substantial age-related changes. Because
of the conflicting observations, there is no general agreement on
the immune response changes that occur during senescence, although
most data support the view that aging is associated with a restructuration
involving each component of the IS, as well as their interactions
(2,9,13-15).
In order to establish the reference values, our group has performed
a study on the age-related changes both in laboratory animals (mice)
and in human subjects in the most representative immune cell types,
i.e. the phagocytes (peritoneal macrophages from mice and neutrophiles
from peripheric human blood), lymphocytes (from peritoneum and the
immunocompetent organs of laboratory animals and from human peripheric
blood) and "natural killer" (NK) from the same locations
that the lymphocytes. In these three cell types we have analyzed
different functions, which are listed in Table 1. In the phagocytes,
the following functions linked to the phagocytic process have been
investigated: (a) Adherence to tissues. (b) Mobility to infectious
focus or chemotaxis. (c) Ingestion or phagocytosis of foreing material
and (d) digestion capacity of this material through the production
of intracellular free radicals, namely superoxide anion. In lymphocytes
the functions analyzed have been: (a) Adherence to tissues. (b)
Migration ability that allows arrival to the site of antigen recognition.
(c) Prolipherative response to the "foreign", antigens
or mitogens. (d) Production of cytokines needed to support proliferation,
such as the IL-2. In the NK cells, the study has focused on its
cytotoxic action against tumour cells.
It has been pointed out that human immunosenescence may differ from
that of mice because of the difference in many physiological characteristics
between the two species. Nevertheless, the experimental data from
several laboratories, including our own, show similar age related
immune changes in humans and mice, although, because of their great
differences in life span, aproximately 100 years for humans and
2 years for mice. The senescent changes of the above mentioned functions
are summarized in Table 1. It seems that some functions (like adherence)
increase continuously with age, whereas other (such as lymphoproliferative
response, production of IL-2 and NK) increase in the adult, with
respect to the young, and decrease significantly in the aged. On
the other hand there are functions, like chemotaxis and phagocytosis
that decline progressively since youth to old age. This explains
that for a function that follows the same kinetics that lymphoprolipheration,
when a comparison is performed between the values found in very
young subjects (2-3 months old mice, which are usually used in immunological
studies) and the values obtained in old mice (22 months of age),
no significant differences are found. Likewise, the comparison of
the values obtained in very young mice and those from "mature"
mice (l4-17 months old, which some researchers may consider old
animals) could lead us to accept that this immune function increases
with age. The above may explain many of the contradictory results,
wich as previously noted are obtained in the study of immunosenescence.
It is also very interesting that, in human subjects, the proliferative
response of lymphocytes to the mitogen fitohemaglutinin, PHA (a
typical mitogen for human T lymphocytes) and the production of IL-2
(two fundamental functions which are the most sensitive to the psychological
and physiological factors that influence the immune system and health)
shows the greatest response at the age of 30-39 years in men and
at 40-49 years in women. Afterwards there is a significant decline
in these functions, in both genders, until the seventies. It is
worth noting that in this decade when the maximum mortality rate
occurs in the developed countries (in which mean life expectancy
is 72 and 78 years for men and women, respectively). Another interesting
finding is that the above mentioned two functions, the lymphoproliferative
response and the production of IL-2, are found at the same level
in human subjects in the age range 80-104 year old than in the adult.
This confirms the opinion already offered by some authors that the
individuals who reach that advanced age are those endowed with a
very adequate IS, and more especifically have lymphocytes T showing
a very good functional competence. This may be due to the fact that
these cells are better preserved, by themselves or as the result
of other factors that influence their correct functioning. In any
case, these results confirm that the IS is an excellent marker of
health and longevity.
In short, we can conclude that with the passage of time the IS "reestructures"
itself, as suggested by some researchers. It is interesting that,
in general, the age-related changes in the IS are expressed, on
the one hand in a lower response in those aspects that could be
of benefit, and on the other hand in an exaggerated response in
those activities that, although initially have a defensive role,
become detrimental if they are produced in excess (2,9,15). Thus,
in senescence, immune functions such as adherence to tissue substrates,
and production of cytoquines of the proinflammatory type like TNFa,
are those that show a stimulation (Table 1). The activated functions
are precisely those more markedly related to an oxidative state
of the subject (16,17), in agreement with the hypothesis that the
aged organism is more oxidized (18), as we will discuss below. |
| |
|
 |
THE
IMMUNE SYSTEM AS A MARKER OF BIOLOGICAL AGE |
| |
The concept of "biological age"
or "functional age" arises as a consequence of the different
rate of the physiological changes in every member of a population
of the same chronological age (19). This concept, first introduced
by the insurance companies of the USA, is useful to assess the level
of aging experienced by each individual, and therefore his life
expectancy. In order to calculate the "biological age",
a number of parameters should be determined. Aging is associated
with a great number of changes at all levels of biological organization,
influencing in different ways the diverse systems of each subject
and the diverse individuals of each species. Therefore, there is
a need to select a number of biochemical, physiological and psychological
parameters that change with age and can be subjected to statistical
analysis to reveal the relations between "biological age",
chronological age, health loss and life expectancy. The most exhaustive
investigation on these subjects has been performed by Borkan and
Norris (20) on about one thousand men enrolled in the study of human
aging of the Gerontological Center of Baltimore. This study showed
that, although it is not possible to calculate an "integrated
biological age" for an individual (since each physiological
system may have a particular biological age different of that of
the other systems), the finding that certain parameters or biomarkers
are "more aged" than those of the majority of the subjects
of the same chronological age is linked to a greater probability
to die prematurely. These biomarkers include those related to respiratory
function, systolic arterial tension and reaction times in psychometric
tests. The Baltimore study did not include the above mentioned immune
parameters, which presently are considered essential and very representative
of the "true" biological age of a subject. Thus, a positive
relation has been shown between a good function of the T cells or
the NK and longevity. Accordingly, a fact that confirms the key
role of the IS on health and longevity is that the centenarians
who reach that very advanced age in good health are those showing
a perfect preservation of the immune cell functions, that show values
like those of adult subjects (21), as already noted.
In relation to the above, our group planned several years ago to
test if the above immune parameters, standardized in mice and humans,
can be used as markers of biological age. This requires that the
parameters show a relation with life expectancy, which could be
only demonstrated in mice (because of its short life span of approximately
two years). In order to carry out this project, we have relied on
a model of premature aging , in the mouse, in which is quite evident
the relation betwen the immune competence of a subject and its life
span. This model, that provides another proof of the relation between
the nervous and the immune system, relies on the differences in
performance among mice of the same sex and chronological age when
subjected to a behavioral (exploration) test in a simple T-maze.
We have shown that the animals that fail the test, are"biologically
older", i.e. suffer premature senescence. This concept is in
agreement with the fact that these mice have a prematurely aged
IS, with the diverse functional parameters investigated (phagocytes,
NK cells and lymphocytes) showing values characteristic of animals
of an older chronological age. Moreover, these prematurely aging
mice also showed higher levels of anxiety and emotionality and a
neurochemistry similar to that of an older chronological age. The
confirmation that such parameters were markers of biological age
was provided by the fact that the mice showing a prematurely aged
behavioral competence had a significantly decreased life span (22-28).
|
| |
|
 |
WHY
DOES IMMUNOSENESCENCE OCCUR? |
| |
It has been demonstrated that aging
is accompanied by changes in the immune function and that these
changes are excellent markers of biological age and therefore of
probable longevity. This justifies many studies, including our own,
to identify the mechanisms responsible for the age-related immune
dysfunctions. It is obvious that when these mechanisms are elucidated
it will be possible to develop strategies to retard immunosenescence
and thereby to preserve health and obtain a satisfactory longevity.
Before reviewing the mechanisms of imnunosenescence, we will summarize
the main facts that underly the aging process.
Aging is linked to a decline of the homeostasis mechanisms of the
body with concomitant functional changes, which trigger diverse
pathologies that are quite frequent in old age and may even cause
death. Of the about 300 theories that, according to Medvedev (29)
have been enunciated to explain why takes place the general deterioration
of aging, that of the "free radicals", proposed by Harman
in 1956 (30), and developed by him (31) and other researchers, among
whom stands out Miquel (32-33), probably is the most widely accepted.
According to this theory, the progressive deleterious oxidation,
that is a result of the use of oxygen in respiration to support
the life-maintaining metabolic processes, leads to the functional
decline linked to aging. The oxygen free radicals (FR) produced
in our cells are highly reactive, and therefore they injure all
kind of biomolecules, i.e.: lipids, proteins and genetic materials.
Since the greatest production of FR and reactive oxygen species
(ROS) takes place in the cellular organelles that carry out respiration,
i.e. the mitochondria, these organelles are probably the main target
of the respiration-linked oxygen stress. In agreement with this
view, a fast-increasing amount of data shows that the mitochondrial
damage caused by the FR results in a loss of bioenergetic competence
that leads to the aging and death of cells and therefore of the
organism (33).
In order to protect themselves against oxygen toxicity, the cells
have developed a variety of antioxidant mechanisms that prevent
the formation of FR or neutralize them after they are produced.
However, these defensive systems are not perfect and thus when the
formation of ROS exceeds the antioxidant protection there is an
oxidative stress, with resulting cell injury (34).
Despite the above, we should consider that oxygen is essential for
life and that ROS, in certain amounts, are needed for many physiological
processes that are essential for our survival (16-18). Therefore,
the functions of our organisms are based on a perfect balance between
the levels of pro-oxidants (ROS) and those of antioxidants. It is
the loss of this balance, because of an excess in the production
of the first or an insufficient availability of the last, what leads
to the oxidative stress that underlies ROS-related disease and aging
(35).
Despite the yet scant work on this subject, but based on it and
on the work of our laboratory, it can be maintaned that immunosenescence
is produced by the same mechanisms responsible for aging of all
cellular components of the organism, i.e.: the oxidation resulting
from the necessary use of oxygen and the damaging effects of FR
in uncontrolled amounts (36).
The IS provides a good example of the need to maintain oxidation
under control to preserve an adequate functional state. In order
to carry out a great proportion of their functions, the immune cells
must produce ROS, with the activated leucocytes being a very important
source of oxidation (16-18). Moreover, it should be considered that
these cells are especially vulnerable to oxidation because of the
high content of polyunsaturated fatty acids of their membranes,
the key role of intracellular signalling related with these membranes
and the gene expression required for their defensive function. In
view of this, if it is important to preserve in any cell the mentioned
antioxidant/oxidant balance, it is even more important to preserve
that balance in the cells of our defensive system, since that equilibrium
conditions their functional competence. The changes that occur in
the function of the immune cells with aging are due in great proportion
to the "chronic oxidative stress" to which they are exposed
in the course of time. We have been able to confirm this in a study
of the evolution experimented by the immune functions, testing them
along the months of life of the mice in the hours of survival to
an "acute oxidative stress" caused by a septicemia (Table
1). Thus, in animals in which an "endotoxic shock" is
induced by injection of baterian lipopolisacharide (LPS, from E.
coli), which show a 100% mortality in 30 hours after provoking the
infection, the kinetics of the investigated function is basically
the same observed in the study of aging (17). It is well known that
the endotoxic shock, one of the main causes of death in the intensive
care units, is the oxidative stress produced by immune cells in
their attempt to protect us against infections, that leads to death
of the patient. Moreover, recent studies of our group have widened
this parallelism not only to the immune functions, but also to the
levels of oxidant and proinflammatory compounds as well as of antioxidants
in the cells of the defensive system (Table 2), which evolve in
a similar fashion in the hours after LPS injection than in several
months of normal aging. |
| |
|
 |
INVOLVEMENT
OF THE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN THE PROCESSES OF AGING: THEORY OF THE OXIDATION/INFLAMMATION |
| |
A logical question, once the role
of the immune system is known, is if the age-related changes and
the cause of these changes, namely a "chronic oxidative stress"
are only one more of the results of the oxidative alterations that
take place with the passage of time or if they can be an important
cause of those changes.
We must remember that the immune cells in order to fullfill their
defensive function show an inflammatory response, producing factors
(such as TNFa and ROS) which support the inflammation and oxidation
processes that allow the eliminatioon of the "foreign".
Since, as already pointed out, the oxidant and pro-inflammatory
factors are increased with age, a new theory of aging, namely the
"inflammation theory", is being developed. In fact, a
transcription factor as ubiquituous as the NF-kB, which is involved
with the expression of genes of oxidant and inflammatory compounds
(such as the TNFa, the enzymes of the inducible nitric oxide synthase
type (iNOS, productor of nitric oxide, or the cyclooxigenase 2 (COX-2),
show a great activation in the immune cells in situations of oxidative
stress (16-18), as it happens in aging (37). This could lead to
a "vicious circle" that would stimulate even more the
oxidative stress. A personal view of the facts in support of this
inflammation /oxidation theory of aging is that our IS, with the
passage of time, has had to face numerous foreign agents, which
has resulted in a "wear-and-tear" condition and concomitant
"chronic oxidative stress", which although generally present
in all cells of the organism, would be more striking in those of
the IS because of their role as producers of oxidant and inflammatory
factors to support their everyday work. With the passage of time,
this increase in inflammatory and oxidant factors would involve
all cells of the organism, with the differentiated-postmitotic populations
being the most vulnerable.
On the other hand, as a result of the oxidative injury that immune
cells suffer with age, these cells would lose some of their capacity
to regulate their own redox balance, which would result in the above
mentioned vicious circle or, more precisely, in "a vicious
spiral", since as a matter of fact the situation becomes progressively
worse and there is no possibility of returning to the initial oxidative-inflammatory
homeostasis. Those senescent changes of the immune cells could also
become evident as an altered intracellular signalling, that makes
them respond in a diffeerent way to the incoming stimuli (9). Therefore,
the communication between the regulatory systems would be impaired,
in agreement with a concept proposed at the beginning of the past
decade as one of the most logical theories of aging, according to
which senescence is associated with a failure of the neuroendocrine-immune
communication (38). In agreement with this theory, the experimental
data confirm that with age not only there is an alteration of the
responses of the nervous, the endocrine and the immune system, but
also of the ability to communicate between them (39-40). Our group
has confirmed that the functional impairment of immune cells with
aging renders them "deaf" to the messages from the nervous
system that reaches them (37-39). It seems probable that the cause
of this impairment of the regulatory systems and their communication
is the oxidative stress that results in the above mentioned changes
and associated homeostatic failure leading to the age-related increase
in morbility and mortality. |
| |
|
 |
STRATEGIES
TO REVITALIZE THE IMMUNE FUNCTION IN AGING: INGESTION OF ANTIOXIDANT
COMPOUNDS |
| |
Since there is already some understanding
of the mechanisms responsible for immunosenescence, it is possible
to develop procedures to modulate them in order to preserve a better
immune function in the aging organism. In this respect, one of the
most adequate strategies relies on the use of antioxidant compounds.
Presently, there is a wealth of experimental data suggesting that
indeed the administration of antioxidants, many of which also possess
anti-inflammatory properties, can normalize the balance between
the levels of oxidation and inflammation and those of the antioxidant
defenses, thus decreasing the oxidative stress. |
| |
|
 |
THE
ANTIOXIDANTS IN THE AGING IMMUNE SYSTEM |
| |
The antioxidant compounds, which
are able to prevent the production of ROS or to neutralize them,
can be endogenous or exogenous. The first are present in our organism
in order to insure the presence of the right levels of ROS compatible
with adequate physiological functions, preventing both an excessive
production or accumulation of ROS and the pathological processes
triggered by them (41). When there is a decrease in the levels of
endogenous antioxidants, often caused because they are spent neutralizaing
an excess of ROS, the antioxidant defenses can be raised by administering
in the diet the adequate amounts of endogenous or exogenous antioxidant
compounds.
Among the exogenous antioxidants, probably the best known are the
vitamins C and E and the carotenes, although others such as the
flavonoids and the lipoid acid and other thiolic compounds (which
raise the intracellular levels of reduced glutathione, GSH) are
being incorporated to the already long list of antioxidants used
in gerontological research (41).
Vitamin C or ascorbic acid and GSH, the two most important intracellular
water-soluble antioxidants, which act in collaboration, are very
effective against the growth of virus, and play a key role in the
defense system, protecting the organism against infections, cancers
and many other diseases. Vitamin E, the main antioxidant in cell
membranes (to which it protects against peroxidation damage), works
synergistically with ascorbic acid and GSH in the defense against
virus infections and protects the circulating LDL against an excessive
oxidation (42). The carotenoids also have a protective role against
cancer and coronary disease. Similar functions have the flavonoids,
which act inhibiting the enzymes implicated in the metabolism of
arachidonic acid, thus preventing many pathological processes like
cancers and vascular diseases (41). A group of compounds like taurine,
thioproline and N-acetylcisteine, among others, provide GSH to our
organism, showing important favorable effects on health owing to
both their ability to increase the GSH levels, and to its direct
antioxidant and anti-inflammatory action, which results in preservation
of mitochondrial function (41) and improved cell survival. Considering
that all cell functions depend to a high degree on the redox reactions
of the thiol compounds, the preservation of adequate levels of GSH
or of other thiols during aging is essential for an adequate activity
of cells in general and especially of those of the IS, and therefore
for health of the aging subjects.
In agreement with the above, the favorable action on the aging process
of antioxidants like vitamins C and E, the thiolic precursors of
GSH and the flavonoids is precisely their ability to raise the reducing
power, thereby protecting against the oxidative stress associated
with aging. In fact it has been shown that the organelles and cells
of the aged animals contain less GSH than those of the young, and
this decrease becomes more striking at the age when mortality shows
a marked increase. Thus the administration of antioxidants able
to increae life expectancy in experimental animals may be effective
because of their protective effect against oxidative stress and
more especifically against the effects of this stress on the DNA
of mitochondria and the GSH loss in these organelles (35). These
favorable effects, at least as regards the vitamins C and E are
obtained with the administration of doses much higher than those
indicatd in the RDA and present in the usual vitamin nutritional
supplements (37).
Many research groups, including our own, have confirmed that these
antioxidants are consumed to support the functions of our immune
system. Therefore, in the performance of their function the immune
cells may exhaust their reserves of antioxidants (43). This could
explain, both in experimental animals and in human subjects, the
improvement of the functional competence of the IS, in the adult
age, after the in vitro incorporation or the supplementation in
vivo of several exogenous antioxidants such as vitamin C, vitamin
E, and thiols like thioproline or N-acetylcisteine (41-48).
If we consider that aging is associated with a production of higher
amounts of ROS, often accompanied by nutritional defficiencies and
significant declines in the levels of antioxidant defense (35,41),
is seems evident that diet supplementation with these kind of compounds
could have a favorable effect on the neutralization of oxidative
stress, thus restoring the lost oxidant/antioxidant balance. This
justifies the present studies to find out if the administration
of antioxidants might have a stimulating effect on the functions
of our defense system in old age. This line of work has provided
very encouraging results (Table 1 and 2), with improvement of health
conditions and prevention of many pathological conditions linked
to oxidative stress (49-52). This is agreement with the fact that
one the most convincing observations that support the oxidation
theory of aging is that there is an increase in the life expectancy
of some laboratory animals which consumed antioxidant-supplemented
diets (28,53). Moreover the positive effects of the antioxidants
is more evident in the immune cells of aged subjects than in those
of the adult, with larger doses being required to observe the same
favorable effect with increasing age (54). Thus, in a Spanish population
the ingestion of vitamin C and vitamin E improved significantly
the functional competence of immune cells in aged subjects (37,48-49).
Indeed, the antioxidant supplementation brought up the levels of
immune function to the values found in 30-35 yers old individuals
(at which age humans show the most competent IS function), with
the supplementation being able to stimulate those functions which
were depressed and to depress those that were overstimulated (Table
1). The regulatory action of these vitamins lasted approximately
six months, with most values obtained in the aged subjects returning
to the initial levels after spending that period of time without
the antioxidant supplementation. The modulating action of the antioxidants
on the immune functions is more striking in those subjects in which
it is more impaired, as ascertained by us both in humans and in
experimental animals. In elderly subjects showing depression or
cardiopathy, diet supplementation with antioxidant vitamins was
more effective for IS function improvement than in subjects of the
same age, who, although having the impaired immune function characteristic
for that age, could be considered quite healthy (49). On the other
hand, the thiolic antioxidants showed a more significant favorable
effect on the immune functions of mice suffering an infectious process
after injection of LPS (48,55), increasing their survival, as well
as in mice showing premature aging, in which the antioxidant supplementation
of the diet increased their longevity (28).
Since the positive action of the antioxidants on the IS is expressed
in an increase of the functions that are depressed and a decrease
of those that are excessively active, the antioxidants can not be
considered general immunostimulants. In fact they may bring each
immune function to its optimum level in situations in which it is
impaired by oxidative stress, thus acting as immunomodulators (48).
This modulating ability appears to be focused at the level of the
ubiquituous intracellular factors implicated in oxidation and inflammation,
such as the NF-kB (37). This regulatory role would be performed
not only by the IS, but also by the other regulatory systems. As
a matter of fact it is accepted that the antioxidants play a role
in the recovery of a great number of nervous functions (35,41).
In addition, in the prematurely aging mice the ingestion of antioxidants
decreases the oxidative stress (Table 2), improves the behavioral
response and increases longevity. This suggests that the oxidative
stress that appears to play a fundamental role in the aging of both
the IS and the nervous system, can be counteracted to certain degree
by antioxidant administration and that antioxidant diet supplementation
may be a useful procedure to neutralize or retard the age-related
homeostatic impairment, which would provide an explanation for its
favorable role in reducing the morbidity and mortality of aging
populations. |
| |
|
 |
CONCLUSIONS |
| |
In view of the esential
role of the immune system in the preservation of health and functional
longeviy, it is assumed that the usefulness of diet supplementation
with antioxidants for preventing pathological aging and increasing
longevity may be due to the fact that this supplementation causes
a "rejuvenation" of the immune function. It may be that
a beter immune system is the cause of a greater longevity, or on
the other hand it is also possible that the better immune functions
may be only a consequence of an improved general homeostasis of
the organisms. In any case there is no doubt that preserving a functionally
"young" immune system, despite the passing years, is an
excellent strategy for preserving the quality of life.
Acknowledgements
This work has been supported in part by MCYT (BFI2001-1218) and
CM (08.5/0061/2001) grants. I wish to thank Dr. Miquel for his
help in the preparation of this manuscript.
|
| |
|
| |
|
TABLE 1. Changes
with ageing in different functions of immune cells. Effects
of a diet supplemented with antioxidants
|
| Cells |
Function
|
Effects of Ageing
|
Effects of Antioxidants*
|
| 1. Phagocytes |
Adherence
Chemotaxis
Phagocytosis
Digestion
|
>
<
<
<
|
|
| 2. Lymphocytes |
Adherence
Migration
Proliferation
IL-2 release
|
>
<
<
<
|
<
>
>
>
|
| 3. NK |
Cytotoxicity |
<
|
>
|
>: Increase. <:
Decrease. * The diet supplementation with antioxidants counteracts
the age-related
changes in the immune functions
bringing them to the normal adult values. |
|
| |
|
| |
|
TABLE 2. Changes
with ageing, in leucocytes, of different oxidant/inflammatory
parameters and antioxidant defences. Effects of a diet supplemented
with antioxidants
|
| |
Parameter
|
Effects of Ageing
|
Effects of Antioxidants*
|
| 1. Oxidants |
Extr.Superox. a.
PGE2
TNFa release
GSSG
|
|
|
| 2. Antioxidants
|
GSH
SOD
CAT
GPx
Gr
|
<
<
<
<
<
|
|
| >: Increase. <: Decrease.
Extr. Superox. a.= Extracellular Superoxide anion. PGE2
= Prostaglandine E2.. GSSG = oxidate glutathione. SOD = superoxide
dismutase. CAT = catalase. GPx = glutathione peroxidase. Gr
= glutathione reductase. * The diet supplementation with antioxidants
counteracts the age-related changes in the oxidative stress
parameters bringing them to the normal adult values. |
|
| |
|
| |
|
 |
REFERENCES |
| |
- Wayne SJ, Rhyne RL, Garry PJ, Goodwin JS (1990) Cell-mediated
immunity as a predictor of morbility and mortality in subjects
over 60. J Gerontol 45, M45-48.
- De la Fuente M (1998) Las defensas contra la infección,
inmunidad y envejecimiento.En: El problema del envejecimiento
(Barja, G.ed.) Madrid AKAL. pp. 61-89.
- Delves PJ, Roitt IM (2000) The immune system. New England
J Med 37-49.
- Delves PJ, Roitt IM (2000) The immune system. New England
J Med 108-117.
- Besedovsky H, Sorkin E (1977) Network of the immune-neuroendocrine
interactions. Clin Exp Immunol 27, 1-12.
- Besedovsky H, Del Rey A (1996) Immune-neuro-endocrine interactions:
facts and hypotheses. Endocrin Rev 17, 64-102.
- De la Fuente M (1999) Modulation of immune function by neuropeptides.
Current Trends Immunol 2, 111-22.
- Downing JEG, Miyan JA (2000) Neural immunoregulation: emerging
roles for nerves in immune homeostasis and disease. Immunol
Today 21, 281-289.
- Pawelek G, Effros C, Caruso C, Remarque E, Barnett Y, Solana
R (1999) Tcells and aging. Front Biosci 4, 216-69.
- Aspinall R (2000) Longevity and the immune response. Biogerontol
1, 273-278.
- Makinodan T, Kay M M B (1980) Age influence on the immune
system. Adv Immunol 29, 287-331.
- Walford RL (1987) MHC-regulation of aging: An extension of
the immunologic theory of aging. En Modern Biological Theories
of Aging. Warner HR, Butler RN, Sprott RL, Schneider EL eds.
pp 243-260. Raven Press New York.
- Ortega E, García JJ, De la Fuente M. (2000) Ageing
modulates some aspects of the non-specific immune response of
murine macrophages and lymphocytes. Exp Physiol 85.5, 519-525.
- Globerson A, Effros R.B (2000) Ageing of lymphocytes and lymphocytes
in the aged. Immunol Today 21, 515-521.
- Lord J M, Butcher S, Killampali V, Lascelles D, Salmon M (2001)
Neutrophil ageing and immunosenescence. Mech Ageing Develop
122, 1521-1535.
- Knight JA (2000) Review: Free Radicals, Antioxidants, and
Immune System. Ann Clin Lab Sci 30, 145-158.
- Victor VM, De la Fuente M (2002) N-acetylcysteine improves
in vitro the function of macrophages from mice with endotoxin-induced
oxidative stress. Free Radical Res 36, 33-45.
- Cascales M (1999) Extrés oxidativo. Envejecimiento
y enfermedad. Instituto de España. Madrid.
- Benfante R, Reed R, Brody J (1985) Biological and social predictors
of health in an agin cohort. J Chron Dis 38, 175-181.
- Borkan A, Norris AH (1980) Assessment of biological age using
a profile of physiological parameters. J Gerontol 35, 177-184.
- Franceschi C, Monti D, Sansoni P, Cossarizza A (1995) The
immunology of exceptional individuals: the lesson of centenarians.
Immunol Today 16, 12-16.
- Guayerbas N, Puerto M, Victor VM, Miquel J, De la Fuente M.
(2002) Leukocyte function and life span in a murine model of
premature immunosenescence. Exp Gerontol. 37, 249-256.
- Guayerbas N, Catalan M, Victor VM, Miquel J, De la Fuente
M (2002) Relation of behaviour and macrophage function to life
span in a murine model of premature immunosenescence. Behav
Brain Res 134, 41-48.
- De la Fuente M, Miñano M, Victor V M, Del Rio M, Ferrandez
M D, Diez A, Miquel J (1998) Relation between exploratory activity
and immune function in aged mice: a preliminary study. Mech
Ageing Dev 102, 263-77.
- Viveros MP, Fernandez B, Guayerbas N, De la Fuente M (2001)
Behavioral characterization of a mouse model of premature immunosenescence.
J Neuroimmunol 114, 80-88.
- Guayerbas N, De la Fuente M (2003) An impairment of phagocytic
function is linked to a shorter life span in two strains of
prematurely aging mice. Dev. Comp. Immunol. 27, 339-350.
- De la Fuente M, Hernanz A, Medina S, Guayerbas N, Fernández
B, Viveros MP (2003) Characterization of monoaminergic systems
in brain regions of prematurely ageing mice. Neurochem. Int.
43, 165-172.
- Guayerbas N. (2003) Cambios con la edad en la función
inmune en un modelo murino de envejecimiento prematuro. Efecto
de los antioxidantes. Tesis Doctoral. Universidad Complutense
de Madrid.
- Medvedev ZA (1990) An attempt at a rational classification
of theories of aging. Biol Rev 65, 375-98.
- Harman D (1956) Aging: a theory based on free radicals and
radiation chemistry. J Gerontol 11, 298-300.
- Harman D. (1986) Free radical theory of aging: role of free
radicals in the origination and evolution of life, aging and
disease processws. En Free Radicals, Aging and degenerative
diseases (Eds JE Johnson Jr, Walford R, Harman D, Miquel J.
Alan R, Liss, New York. pp:3-49
- Miquel J (1998) An update on the oxygen stress-mitochondrial
mutation theory of aging: genetic and evolutionary implications.
Exp Gerontol 33, 113-26.
- Miquel J , Economos AC, Fleming J, Johnson JE. (1980) Mitochondrial
role in cell aging. Exp Gerontol 15: 575-91.
- Sies H. (1986) Biochemistry of oxidative stress. Angewandte
Chemi 25, 1058-71.
- Sastre J, Pallard_ FV, Garcia de la Asuncion J, Viña
J (2000) Mitochondra, oxidative stress and aging. Free Rad Res
32, 189-98.
- Gracy RW, Talent JM, Kong Y, Conrad CC (1999) Reactive oxygen
species: the unavoidable environmental insult?. Mutat Res 428,
17-22.
- De la Fuente M (2002) La nutrición y el sistema inmunitario
en el envejecimiento. Rev Esp Geriatr Gerontol 37, 17-25.
- Fabris N (1991) Neuroendocrine-immune interactions: a theoretical
approach to ageing. Arch Gerontol Geriat 12, 219-30.
- Medina S, Del Rio M, Ferrandez MD, Hernanz A, De la Fuente
M (1998) Changes with age in the modulation of natural killer
activity of murine leukocytes by gastrin-releasing peptide,
neuropeptide Y and sulfated cholecystokinin octapeptide. Neuropeptides
32, 549-55.
- De la Fuente M, Del Rio M, Medina M (2001) Changes with aging
in the modulation by neuropeptide Y of murine peritoneal macrophage
functions. J Neuroimmunol 116, 156-167.
- De la Fuente M (2000) Papel de los antioxidantes en la nutricion
del anciano. Rev Esp Geriatr Gerontol 35 (S4), 63-71.
- De la Fuente M, Carazo M, Correa R, Del Rio M (2000) Changes
in macrophage and lymphocyte functions in guinea-pigs after
different amounts of vitamin E ingestion. British J Nutr 84,
25-29.
- Hernanz A, Collazos M E, De la Fuente M (1990) Effect of age,
culture media and lymphocyte presence in ascorbate content of
peritoneal macrophages from mice and guinea pigs during phagocytosis.
Int Arch Allergy appl Immununol 91, 166-70.
- Del Rio M, Ruedas G, Medina S, Victor V M, De la Fuente M
(1998) Improvement by several antioxidants of macrophage function
in vitro. Life Sci 63, 871-81.
- Ferrandez MD, Correa R, Del Rio M, De la Fuente M (1999) Effects
in vitro of several antioxidants on the natural killer function
of aging mice. Exp Gerontol 34, 675-85.
- Blanco B, Ferrandez MD, Correa R, Del Rio M, Guaza C, Hernanz
A, De la Fuente M (1999) Changes in several functions of murine
peritoneal macrophages by N-acetylcysteine and thioproline ingestion.
Comparative effect between two strains of mice. BioFactors 10,
179-185.
- Correa R, Del Rio M, De la Fuente M (1999) Improvement of
murine immune functions in vitro by thioproline. Immunopharmacology
44, 281-291.
- De la Fuente M, Victor V M (2000) Antioxidants as modulators
of immune function. Immunol Cell Biol 78, 49-54.
- De la Fuente M, Ferrandez MD, Burgos MS, Soler A, Prieto A,
Miquel J (1998) Immune function in aged women is improved by
ingestion of vitamins C and E. Can J Physiol Pharmacol 76, 373-80.
- De la Fuente M, Ferrandez MD, Del Rio M, Burgos MS, Miquel
J (1998) Enhancement of leukocyte functions in aged mice supplemented
with the antioxidant thioproline. Mech Ageing Dev 104, 213-25.
- Correa R, Blanco B, Del Rio M, Victor V, Guayerbas N, Medina
S, De la Fuente M (1999) Effect of a diet supplemented with
thioproline on murine macrophage function in a model of premature
ageing. BioFactors 10, 195-200.
- Puerto M, Guayerbas N, Victor VM, De la Fuente M (2002) Effects
of N-acetylcysteine on macrophage and lymphocyte functions in
a mouse model of premature ageing. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 73,
797-804.
- Miquel J, Economos AC (1979) Favorable effects of the antioxidants
sodium and magnesium thiazolidine carboxylate on the vitality
and life span of Drosophila and mice. Exp Gerontol 14, 279-85.
- De la Fuente M, Miquel J, Catalan MP, Victor VM, Guayerbas
N (2002) The amount of thiolic antioxidant ingestion needed
to improve several immune functions is higher in aged than in
adult mice. Free Rad Res 36, 119-126.
- Victor VM, Guayerbas N, Garrote D, Del Rio M, De la Fuente
M (1999) Modulation of murine macrophage function by N-acetylcysteine
in a model of endotoxic shock. BioFactors 10, 347-357.
|
| |
|
| |
|
|